John Sudler Isaacs and his times (II)

In my last post, I began with a look at the site of the John S. Isaacs cannery at the intersection Route 30 and Cedar Creek Road, and talked in broad terms of how farming in Sussex County transitioned from horse-drawn machinery to mechanization. Isaacs and his family were big players in this transition, not only in the use of gas-powered tractors and modern cultivation methods, but also in their early adoption of a modern, integrated business model for farm to factory production of lima beans and poultry. In this posting, I will look at John Sudler Isaacs’ early life as the youngest son of none-too-prosperous farmer John Ponder Isaacs; his own first foray as a tenant farmer; and his rapid transition into a major grower and packer of vegetables. The third and final installment of this series will look at Isaacs’ innovative venture into poultry farming.

Before going further, I would like to give extensive credit to W. Edwin Kee, author of John Sudler Isaacs: A Sussex County Visionary, who worked with Hobby Isaacs Sr. and Jr. to assemble a biography of their father and grandfather, respectively. It would have been infinitely more difficult to create this posting without Kee’s book, from which I took the major part of the material presented here, with the exception of the family photographs and a few of the present-day shots I took myself. Please see the A note on sources at the end of this posting for more details.

John Sudler Isaacs ca. 1940
John Sudler Isaacs ca. 1940 (collection of Hobby Isaacs, Jr.; used by permission)


John Ponder Isaacs, father of J. S. Isaacs, in a pea field (date unknown)
John Ponder Isaacs, father of J. S. Isaacs, in a pea field, date unknown (collection of Hobby Isaacs, Jr.; used by permission)


John Sudler Isaacs and his siblings; l to r, Hilda, Edgar, Mae, and John
John Sudler Isaacs and his siblings; l to r, Hilda, John, Mae, and Edgar (collection of Hobby Isaacs, Jr.; used by permission)


John S. Isaacs was the son of John Ponder Isaacs (1854 – 1933). The elder Isaacs was the sixth of the eleven children of Minos Isaacs (1813 – 1871) and the only child of his second wife Lovey Elliott (1822 – 1857). When Minos Isaacs died intestate, the Sussex County Orphan’s Court divided his estate of 510 acres among his wife and eleven children, thus leaving each heir with only a small plot. John Ponder Isaacs ended up selling his share to his stepmother in 1892 and moved to the Greenwood area, where he bought a small farm and struggled to make a living on poorly drained soil that lost its fertility quickly. When John S. Isaacs was born in 1889, the third of four children, his father lacked capital to make improvements to or expand the farm he would later buy, and so continued to eke out a living. While not impoverished, the Isaacs family led a difficult existence, one that may have imbued John S. Isaacs with a drive to make a better life for himself.

When he married Mary C. Lofland in 1908, John Sudler Isaacs had had no more than six years of schooling and was working on a nearby tenant farm; according to Kee, the couple had to borrow money just to buy a table and chairs to sit on. By 1914, with a wife, infant son J. Howard and four year old son Earle to support, Isaacs was highly motivated to generate more income.

Draper Canning Co. in Slaughter Neck, ca. 1940 or later
Draper Canning Co. in Slaughter Neck, ca. 1940 or later; John S. Isaacs was a tenant on the adjacent farm and supplied this cannery with vegetables (collection of Hobby Isaacs, Jr.; used by permission)


Remnants of Draper Canning Co., Slaughter Neck
Remnants of Draper Canning Co., Slaughter Neck; cannery building and chimney are gone, machine shop / garage building are all that remain.

In 1915, John began an association with George H. Draper Jr. that was to last 15 years when he assumed the tenancy of the farm adjacent to Draper’s Slaughter Neck canning factory. The Draper family was a canning dynasty in those days; George H. Draper Jr. operated canneries in Milford, Frederica, and Slaughter Neck, while another branch of the Draper family operated the Milton cannery formerly owned by the Workmans. At Slaughter Neck, John grew tomatoes, sugar corn, peas and lima beans for the Draper cannery, in a 50-50 deal on the proceeds of crop sales to the cannery. All of the cultivation was done by mule-drawn machines, and the harvesting was done by hand.

Although there is no written record of a plan, John S. Isaacs’ activities from 1915 to 1929 appear to have followed one that would lead him ultimately to owning his own farm. The family owned about a dozen dairy cows and sold the milk, keeping all of the proceeds as was customary for tenant farmers in those years. They also ran a small general store on the farm that was patronized by the Draper cannery workers, adding an additional source of income. He bought a 16-acre tract of timber in 1917, the 50-acre Wells farm in Slaughter Neck in 1928, and finally in 1929 the 110-acre farm Simpson farm on Hummingbird Road north of Milton. With the purchase of the last property, Isaacs was no longer a tenant, but the owner of his own farm. The family moved there from Slaughter Neck as soon as the deal was consummated.

In addition to his farming activities, Isaacs was making himself known and respected in the community, first in 1925 as a trustee of the one-room Prime Hook School his children attended, and then as the Sussex County Receiver of Taxes in 1929. The latter was at least in part due to his declaring himself a Republican and aligning himself with the right people in the county government. More than the additional income he received from these positions, he was forming the social, political, and business connections that would facilitate the growth of his agricultural interests in the long term. His political involvement would increase as time went on.

The Isaacs family continued to supply the Draper Canning Co. with peas, lima beans and sweet corn for packing. Although Isaacs had bought a tractor in 1929, much of the farm labor was still performed by manual labor or mule-drawn machinery. He continued his dairy business and also diversified into timber and lumber from his wooded tract. The breakthrough that would bring major changes to the way John S. Isaacs conducted his business came in 1935, when his son Hobby Sr. suspected that the Draper Canning Co. was underpaying the family for the produce they provided, and informed his father. When Isaacs verified the truth of what his son told him, he made the decision to build his own cannery. With the proceeds of a land sale, a small loan, and his own lumber, John S. Isaacs built his cannery at the intersection of Rt. 30 and Cedar Creek Road; by September of 1936, he was ready to pack that season’s crop of vegetables.


John S. Isaacs bean cannery ca. 1960
John S. Isaacs cannery ca. 1960 (Collection of Hobby Isaacs, Jr.; used by permission)


Steam engine that powered the John S. Isaacs Cannery (Collection of Hobby Isaacs; used by permission)
The cannery was powered by a steam engine (above), and for a time it was used to generate electricity as well (Collection of Hobby Isaacs; used by permission)


Boiler that generated steam for the engine above, date unknown (Collection of Hobby Isaacs, Jr.; used by permission)


Kettles used to cook the vegetables for canning
Kettles used to cook the vegetables for canning (Collection of Hobby Isaacs, Jr.; used by permission)


Cans being cooled by water before being boxed (Collection of Hobby Isaacs, Jr.; used by permission)

John S. Isaacs made a strategic decision with the building of the cannery to not pack tomatoes, relying instead on peas, lima beans and asparagus. It might have seemed counter-intuitive to forgo canning a crop that was ideally suited to the packing process and very much in demand. However, tomatoes were a risky business for both growers and canners. The industry was highly competitive, and tomatoes were a volatile commodity in terms of pricing. Canners contracted with tomato growers for a set price and for a predetermined acreage to be planted, potentially locking themselves into paying higher-than-market prices when there was a bumper crop.

The cannery turned a profit very quickly. The New Deal was pumping money into the American economy, but the real boost came with the outbreak of World War II and the U. S. entry into the conflict. A military force of 15 million men and women at its peak consumed vast amounts of food, not the least of which was canned items, and prices rose steeply. The Isaacs Cannery had been selling under its own label since the start of production, but most of its output was sold to chain stores and other distributors under their private labels. The cannery did sell directly to the military under its own label during the war; the labels were distinct in including a V in the front and a special emblem on the back (designed by Walt Disney).

Canned lima beans sold to the military directly, under the Isaacs Farm label, 1941 – 1945; note the V at top and bottom of the label (Hobby Isaacs Jr. collection; used by permission)
Back of lima bean can; the eagle, stars and merchant ship logo was designed by Walt Disney and presented to the U. S. government; the four stars represent FDR’s “Four Freedoms”  (Hobby Isaacs Jr. collection; used by permission)

By the 1940’s, John S. Isaacs had achieved a level of diversification and integration among a wide variety of activities, and was also buying land. By the time of his death in 1950, he had acquired over 8,000 acres of improved and unimproved farmland. These were all highly notable achievements, but not the crown jewel in his empire; that title would have to be accorded to his poultry farming, which achieved integration on virtually the entire supply chain. That will be the subject of the third and final installment of this series.

J. S. Isaacs in his office, August 1945
J. S. Isaacs in his cannery office, August 1945

A note on sources

I made use of two principal sources for the postings in the John Sudler Isaacs series. The first consists of the recollections of Hobby Isaacs Jr. as well as his extensive collection of photographs and documents pertaining to his grandfather. The second is an 85 page biography titled John Sudler Isaacs: A Sussex County Visionary, by W. Edwin Kee, Jr., published by Delaware Heritage Press in 2009. Edwin Kee is a former Secretary of Agriculture for the state of Delaware, an author of numerous scholarly papers and three books, as well as a respected academician associated with the University of Delaware. Some readers may be familiar with an earlier title of his, Delaware Farming, one of the Images of America series sold in many locations in Delaware. However, he failed to include even one mention of John Sudler Isaacs in that volume, something that did not escape the notice of Isaacs’ son and grandson. The subsequent volume, John Sudler Isaacs: A Sussex County Visionary, was a direct result of his discussions with the Isaacs family.

8 thoughts on “John Sudler Isaacs and his times (II)

  • The ‘kettles’ you mention were called “retorts” in the canning industries. As the industry moved on to “continous cookers” my family business , ELLENDALE CORPORATION, ended up with MANY retorts, few that went to Asia, South American and Mexico canneries , most in storage in Ellendale, cut up as scrap metal . IN FACT, it was during the process of ‘scraping’ these retort’s, that the Ellendale storage , a former old canning house, somehow, caught fire and the building and contents, obsolete used cannery equipment, were a total loss. Talk about Mother Luck.

    • Phil Martin

      This is a really great add-on to the posting! I knew your family business had all kinds of machinery and equipment, but I didn’t make the leap to think to ask you if you had cannery equipment there. Thanks for putting this out there, and I hope readers of the posting take the time to read it.

  • Steve DiGirolamo

    What a strange coincidence…l have a couple of old JSI labels framed on my kitchen wall and walked by then just now and decided to do a search and see if JSI was still in business….came across your blog, read the first story then read this one only to realise out was posted today! Weird…..great story on the farm and cannery, though.

    • Phil Martin

      Thanks for the kind words. The Isaacs family business was dissolved in the early 1960s,
      And JSI died in 1950. But people like you will keep the legacy alive.

  • Phil L

    I found this page after seeing an attractive John Isaacs label for sale online,, and was curious about the Ellendale DE location–I live in MD. Thanks for helping to save even a small but clearly significant piece of local and also food industry history. I am 70 and suspect that if I began a conversation mentioning canneries I would be speaking Greek. I do recall reading in a government publication -perhaps an Agricultural Yearbook, how a passenger traveling through Harford County on the B & O or Pennsylvania RR remarked that the hills appeared to be painted red, due to all the cannery bound tomatoes. This is a very thought provoking blog posting and I am happy to see you included photos of the steam engine that once served multiple duties. Had I been a teen aged boy who lived close by in the operating time of the cannery, I would have begged to help feed the fire and tend the boiler, even for no pay! We have lost much besides tradition, jobs, land, and good foods with the demise of local canning.

    • Phil Martin

      Thanks so much for your response to this post! It so happens I was talking with two gentlemen I met today about John Sudler Isaacs; they have bought his home on Route 1 and were researching the history of his many ventures, including canning.

  • Cindy Isaacs

    In your fascinating research on John S. Isaacs, did it mention anywhere that he had other relatives in Stanley or Withee? My father, John Ward Isaacs and his siblings, grew up in Stanley. John W later married and resided in Withee where he was a John Deere dealer/repairman and also had a printing company. His brother, Virgil, remained in Stanley and owned the John Deere Implement Co for many years. Until my cousin was shown a photo of the label from the cannery, we were unaware of the Isaacs association. I am excited to read more of your posts and research!

    • Phil Martin

      Thank you so much for your interest in this post. I did not pursue a full inquiry into the entire Isaacs genealogy, as I was focused purely on John Sudler Isaacs and his local impact. Doing a full treatment of an entire family can be a major undertaking, one that I do not have the time to do (even as a retiree!). It’s been quite a while since I wrote this post, but if you have any specific questions that you want answered I could try to do that for you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.